Large stretches of MOD Bicester Site A are covered in wartime concrete hardstanding, laid for a very different purpose from modern residential accommodation. Reusing those surfaces may appear economical, especially if the aim is to deploy modular buildings quickly. But the age of concrete alone does not establish whether it is suitable for new structural loads.
What the Published Documents Tell Us
A hardstanding that carries vehicles is not automatically a certified foundation for stacked accommodation modules. Engineers would need to understand thickness, reinforcement, the ground below, movement between slabs and the condition of joints. The published Drainage Design Statement refers to areas where slabs have settled or failed. That observation makes it especially important to distinguish what is known from what remains to be verified by investigation.
Why This Matters
If existing concrete can be reused safely, that might reduce excavation, disruption and cost. If it cannot, replacing or strengthening foundations could affect the timetable, disposal requirements, ground investigation, drainage and the layout itself. Such choices also interact with other site constraints, including buried services and possible contamination. They cannot sensibly be settled by appearance alone.
What Would Actually Establish Whether Reuse Is Safe?
A credible assessment would start with a survey mapping the slabs proposed for reuse, their visible defects and any known alterations. Engineers may then need cores to establish thickness and materials, tests to assess load capacity, and ground investigations to understand what supports the concrete. Just as importantly, the findings must be matched to the actual modular building design. A single-storey unit, a stacked pair of units and a heavy vehicle all impose different demands. Any new pads, anchors or foundations must be designed for the loads and ground conditions they will encounter.
Why does this matter to local residents? Because the promise of a quick, economical conversion depends on what the old site can genuinely provide. If large areas of hardstanding need replacement, excavation could bring added lorry movements, waste disposal, further drainage work and possible investigations of buried services. It could also undermine assumptions used elsewhere in the application. Our campaign is not against repairing an old site in principle. We are asking whether the Government knows how much repair is necessary and whether the full cost has been weighed against sites that already have suitable residential infrastructure.
Questions That Deserve Answers
Our question is straightforward: what structural assessments and load tests will establish whether the proposed accommodation can rely on these surfaces, and will their results be made public? We are not claiming the slabs are incapable of supporting buildings. We are asking for the engineering evidence before their reuse is treated as an assured saving.
Further Reading
Read the published Home Office application documents and the Cherwell planning register. For background guidance, see relevant technical or safety guidance.