It is easy to compare accommodation projects by the price of the buildings. It is much harder to compare the total cost of making those buildings usable for years. At MOD Bicester Site A, the application includes not only modular accommodation but also power arrangements, wastewater treatment, drainage, water storage, access roads and other supporting works. Each is essential to the proposed operation.
What the Published Documents Tell Us
An apparently inexpensive site can become expensive when basic services have to be renewed or installed. Even where engineering solutions are available, they need design, equipment, contractors, permissions, testing, maintenance and eventual removal or replacement. The Home Office’s published application contains preliminary technical reports addressing these systems. The question is whether those separate elements have been brought together in one transparent whole-life financial case.
Why This Matters
There is a wider lesson. The National Audit Office’s March 2024 investigation found that projected costs for the Government’s then-planned large asylum sites had increased and that its analysis suggested they would cost more than hotels when sunk costs were included. That finding does not prove Site A will follow the same course, but it illustrates why assumptions about savings need to be tested rather than taken on trust.
The Hidden Difference Between a Building Cost and a Working Site
Imagine receiving a quotation for a group of prefabricated accommodation units, then discovering that the price does not yet establish how they will be heated, powered, supplied with water or connected to an effective sewage system. That does not make the units defective. It means their price is only one part of the development. In a project of this scale, enabling works can involve investigations, repairs, excavations, new plant, permits and coordination between several utilities. Even relatively ordinary engineering items become consequential when they are multiplied across a large, ten-year residential operation.
This is why our concern is not merely whether the Home Office has a budget line for construction. We want the assumptions, risks and alternatives to be visible together. What happens if the existing concrete cannot carry the proposed buildings? What if a wastewater outfall needs a different route, or the electricity solution requires long-term generators? And who carries the financial risk if detailed designs change? Those questions are relevant to taxpayers everywhere, not just residents near Bicester. A project can be presented as temporary while committing substantial public money to infrastructure that has little alternative use.
Questions That Deserve Answers
Wrong Plan Wrong Site’s current estimate is £338 per person per night, but that is a campaign estimate, not an agreed Government price. A fair comparison must use consistent occupancy assumptions, timescales and cost categories. We are asking for an independently scrutinised business case that accounts for construction, services, running costs, contingencies and decommissioning before major commitments become irreversible.
Further Reading
Read the published Home Office application documents and the Cherwell planning register. For background guidance, see the relevant public evidence.